SEO for criminal defense lawyers: 12× more organic clicks in one year

Shane Scanlon Law defends DUI, PFA and traffic cases in Scranton, PA. In 2025 the firm ran SEO and nothing else: no Google Ads, no paid social. Organic clicks grew from 56 in the first quarter to 672 in the fourth, and the site logged 915 phone and form leads at $20.05 each.

Shane Scanlon Law website, the Scranton criminal defense firm whose SEO Zen Agency runs: home page and Scranton DUI attorney page

12×Organic clicks, Q1 to Q4 2025915Tracked calls and form leads in 2025$20.05Cost per lead, SEO and hosting included1.02Average Google position for the firm’s name in Q4

Organic search only, and it grew every quarter

Criminal defense is a hard search market. People look for a lawyer the day they’re charged, they search by charge and county, and the firms that show up first get the call. Paid clicks for those searches are expensive, so Shane Scanlon Law put its budget into search engine optimization instead.

Because there was no paid search running alongside it, every click in Google Search Console came from organic results. Clicks rose every quarter of 2025, with no plateau, and the click-through rate tripled from 0.28% to 0.85% as rankings improved.

ClientShane Scanlon Law, LLCLocationScranton, PAPractice areasDUI, PFA, traffic citations and criminal defenseServicesMonthly SEO and website hostingPeriodJanuary to December 2025TrackingGoogle Search Console, WhatConverts call and form tracking

Organic clicks per quarter, 202556 clicksQ1 (Jan–Mar)186 clicksQ2 (Apr–Jun)435 clicksQ3 (Jul–Sep)672 clicksQ4 (Oct–Dec)1,349 organic clicks and 278,197 impressions for the year.

Pages for the searches that turn into calls

Someone arrested for DUI in Lackawanna County doesn’t search for a law firm’s name. They search for the charge and the place. The SEO program works on the pages that answer those searches, such as the firm’s Scranton DUI attorney page, and on the signals that help Google trust them.

By the fourth quarter the firm ranked for high-intent searches beyond its own name, including “dui lawyers near me” at an average position of 7.28 and “criminal lawyers scranton pa”.

One page per charge and county, written for the search behind itBranded search held at an average position of 1.02Click-through rate up from 0.28% to 0.85%Fast, hosted site with calls and forms tracked from the first visit

Shane Scanlon Law's Scranton DUI attorney page, one of the practice pages in the firm's SEO program

Leads grew as fast as the clicks

More traffic only matters if it turns into calls. Total leads went from 37 in the first quarter to 432 in the fourth, an 11.7× increase that kept pace with the 12× growth in clicks.

Across the year that was 915 leads: 856 phone calls and 59 web forms. The phone count is every call WhatConverts tracked, answered or not, so the firm sees the real demand its site creates, not only the calls that reached someone.

Q1: 37 leadsQ2: 68 leadsQ3: 378 leadsQ4: 432 leads

Criminal defense SEO questions

It depends on your market and where your site starts. For Shane Scanlon Law, the first quarter of 2025 brought 56 organic clicks, the second 186, the third 435 and the fourth 672. The growth compounded, so the second half of the year carried most of the results.

It can be. This firm ran no paid search at all in 2025, and its site produced 915 tracked calls and form leads at $20.05 each, counting the SEO fee and hosting. Many firms run both; organic search tends to get cheaper per lead as rankings build, while paid clicks keep their price.

Searches that combine a charge with a place, such as “Scranton DUI attorney”, and near-me searches like “dui lawyers near me”. Your own name matters too: People who hear about you still search for you, and you want to be the first result.

Google Search Console shows organic clicks and impressions. Call tracking and form tracking (we use WhatConverts) record every lead the site produces, with its source, so you can see what the program brings in each quarter.

Yes. We run SEO and paid search for law firms in several markets, and we quote a fixed monthly price after a short review of your site and competition.

Related services

Tell us the number you need to move. We’ll show you what’s holding it back, and what fixing it costs.

A plan, price and timeline inside five business days.